Natural Eye Liner

I've got both colors, and I'm happy with their shades. The pencil is very soft, easy to apply and smudge. However, sometimes it smudges too much especially on my eyelids (I've got a bit hooded eyes and oily eye lids so it might be the reason for the smudging). I don't do make up too often, and little smudging does not bother me too much. However I wouldn't recommend the pencil to those that are big fans of perfect flick ;)

Bought three of these eye pencils,the shade which I really adored was blue although it was more like a pale grey/blue sadly that shade has not been available for a while not sure if it has been discontinued,that would be a shame as it was my favourite shade.

This is amazing! I normally use liquid eyeliner to draw a defined line and have never found a pencil which was able to do the same without dragging. This natural eye liner is soft enough to do that. The Black is not quite as jet black as my favourite liquid eyeliner but it gives a great smoky eye look when used with my (free!) Mystical eyeshadow. And it's so gentle that I can use it with my contact lenses without my eyes watering. I think my next purchase may be the grey!

Soft to apply but black can be too harsh a colour. smudges as it says but looked dreadful and needed to be wiped away throughout the day. Not pretty or glamourous.

I was quite happy using my old eye liner, coudn't really fault it. But after using this I'm like OMG! What have I been missing!?! Really does apply so smoothly, great product just makes me want to try more of Lily Lolos products!

Intense black and creamy. I have never tried a eyeliner like this before! Love it!

I read the description ("a smooth line without any pulling or dragging") and thought to myself, "Yeah, they all say that...and then you try to use them and you might as well be trying to use an HB pencil." However, to my astonishment this really is the very first eyeliner pencil I have EVER used which genuinely does not drag the skin on my eyelids. It's almost like liquid eyeliner it goes on so smoothly and easily. How did it take me 38 years to find an eyeliner pencil that actually worked?!? I always thought it was me and that I was born with weirdly crepey eyelids and would never be able to put eyeliner on successfully, but it turns out I just needed a good eyeliner pencil! :)

I'd heard so many good things about this eye liner but I was pretty disappointed with it. The brown has a very red undertone, which has given my eyes a hint of myxomatosis! It didn't go on any more smoothly than my cheaper eye liners either, and smudging seemed to remove it rather than blend it. Worst of all, when I went to sharpen it (it arrived fairly blunt) the wood was very coarse and splintery so it didn't sharpen evenly, and the tip kept on falling off! I have literally sharpened it down by about a third and I still haven't got a nice point. I'm very disappointed in this eye liner. I love Lily Lolo's concealer and foundation but will be sticking to other brands for my eye liner!

I hardly ever review things but thought this deserved a mention as it is literally the best eye liner I have ever used! Better colouring than a normal eye pencil and as easy to use as liquid- it gives amazing, long lasting results. I am so amazed!

Thank you soooo much for this eyeliner, I have it in 3 colours and could not be without it.By far the best that I have tried. It goes on smoothly even on my 50 something years old eyes.

Great product. Only used as I won a free pencil. Stays put, does not slide around and I will NEVER buy a mac eye pencil again. A must for any girl that likes her ey pencils to stay put...!!! Buy now..! nomorepandaeyes

Soft, smooth application AND natural ingredients - just what you need from an eye liner! The shade of brown is perfect for my colouring (light brown hair with darkish brown eyebrows), and I've also tried the blue which is a gorgeous smoky blue colour, great on blue eyes teamed with Pixie Sparkle! I regularly recommend Lily Lolo to friends, particularly this eye liner! Thank you!

It's simply perfect for everyday use, soft and long lasting!!

I bought this eyeliner in brown and find it great for creating a soft smokey effect - something I've found virtually impossible with other brands. I'll definitely be sticking with this from now on. Yet another EXCELLENT product. Thank you!!

Just love this eye liner. It's smooth, really black and easy to draw.

I received a blue liner as a gift and am thoroughly impressed with the shade of blue and the application - it goes on very smoothly and lasts well on my upper lids - however, I don't use it on the bottom lid as it does tend to come off easily. I wear navy liner a lot, but this lighter blue/grey is a lovely change and I am always complimented on it. Definitely recommended!

This liner has an AMAZING pigmentation. Really, I was surprised with how soft and intense this black is. Black and Glossy, beautiful but... since it's so soft, it also tends to smear, so I recommend setting it with a little bit of black shadow.

The best eyeliner I've used as it stays on ALL Day!

I was really looking forward for this grey eyeliner. And what a beautiful shiny colour it was... Was, being the right word allready after 2 hours, because I couldn't see that I used any eyeliner at all after that time (didn't do anything sweaty...) Maybe anyone has a tip? All other Lily Lolo products stay on very wel, just not this... Karin

I love these pencils. Great for anyone with sensitive eyes. Eye liner is something I can't do without and I always worried about what rubbish I was putting on my eyes. Not any more! I have all three colours now but the blue is my favourite - gorgeous!!!!!!!!!!

I was really surprised to find this eye pencil so wonderfully easy to apply to my eyelids, so much so that I could easily do it with 1 hand (no holding eye in place with other). It went on like a dream, gave a perfect line close to my eyes and looked great. However, I noticed it was very wet and still looked wet after a few minutes. This could be good if you like the retro 50's look and want to really stand out. So although I loved the easy application and the fact it's a natural eyeliner......I was a bit unsure. I experimented with it a bit and found if I draw a narrow line on my top eyelid and blend it out, it produces an amazing smokey eye look and yet maintains a very faint, very natural looking base line. It turned out very much like Angelina Jolie evening slight cat eye make-up look and blended really well. I found that the eyeliner could not get too messy after a bit as it was no longer a wet look. This is perfect for me as I can get a really nice subtle evening look without separate eyeliner and 2 shades of eyeshadow. So for a quick evening look it's perfect. I don't think I would use this for daytime but then I tend to just use mascara for daytime.

Pencil was lovely soft, colour was perfect when I put it and it looked really really good. It could have been the perfect pen. But the color spread along the eye immediately when I put it and it was terrible mess. No matter how much colour was put. Unfortunately, I can not use the pen at all and I also can not recommend. I would hope that this would also be a little more permanent.

It was great when i had just put it but after couple hours I had a mess around my eyes. I don't know if I used it too much, is my skin somehow too oily or is it just the product... Anyway I love Lily Lolo products but this one didn't work for me.

Received my pencil as a free gift and like another person wouldn't of normally been my choice of colour, but looks lovely and a lot softer (in texture and appearance) I'm very fair skinned and this looks much better than the black khol liner that i normally wear defines the eyes but without a hard look,love Lily Lolo cosmetics try their foundation much better than Bare Minerals :)

received the grey eyeliner as a free gift, first thoughts mmmm not the colour I would of chosen usually a would choose brown(have been using wet eyeshadow), but sooo glad I tried it WOW! love it, easy to apply and the colour looks fab!

I agree it is soft but I really like it.I'm in my mid forties so don't want anything too harsh anyway. I really need to order another. Thumbs up from Billericay! :-)

I really liked the gray liner. It was soft enough and the shade was perfect. I just would love to get one in the shade of glossy white.

I bought the black eye liner but am finding it way too soft and smudgy for my needs. I like a fairly hard eye liner for my top lid so that I can get a clean line but it's impossible to get a clean line with this. It virtually melts on to the skin. It's probably wonderful for a smudgy line underneath but it's not going to give you a clean line on top.

I have recently purchased a Khaki eyeliner from Lily Lolo, and didn't know what to expect. The eyeliner is a lovely gentle shade which really suits my dark brown eyes and olive skin tone. It is really soft to use and glides on easily with no drag at all. Very impressed with quality and also competitively priced.

I'm not a fan of eyeliners, or at least wasn't till I got this as a freebee with a purchase. I love it. Its creamy, soft, easy to use and the colour (grey) I would have never chosen, but it looks great. Total convert.

This is theeee best eyeliner I have had.so easy to use, and I have sensitive eyes BUT this didn't bother me one bit and the Khaki colour would suit anyone

Love the colour! I am always looking for a grey blue pencil and think I found THE one! It applies easily, and stays on for long.

I am ed from ELF's mineral liners too soft and squidgy. This was a gift and it is great soft but not too much and great staying power. a great staple for those with pale colouring, black harsh

this feels so soft on your eye lids, so know drag. it is very dark so if you want to line then smudge only use a little, as it gos along way.

A really beautiful greyish blue eyeliner. Goes on perectly and stays on for ages. I love it!

If you have brown eyes you MUST try this!! Not at all "80s"!! Very flattering..LOVE IT!

Best eye-liner I've ever used. Gentle but long-lasting with great pigmentation. I find it just the right texture for softening with a smudging brush. Wish LL did a matching mascara!

I have been on the quest for foundation for my pale, dry skin for ages. I am ed! coverage is quite light but I am delighted with the sheer, un powdery result and the range of colours. Hurrah!

I really like that this eye liner is natural. Easy to apply and smudge but I do wish that the staying power was a bit better. it helps to use an eyelid primer first though.

This seductivley smooth, brown eyeliner glides around me eye. The soft texture and colour perfectly contrasts with my dark blue eyes. Instantly defined eyes, without looking harsh. Brown is the new black!

I love this eye liner so much it lovely and soft it look good great in or out side the eye i love it and use it every day

I love love love this eyeliner- it was the first lily lolo product i bought. it's soft and smudgeable but still has staying power if you want a defined line

I use this every day!Its good for any look,it goes on almost wet as it melts into your skin and you can leave it as a hard line or I use a smudger to create a softer look.Great for smokey eyes.

This liner was a bit too soft to use by itself, but it actually smudges quite nice with eyeshadow and a brush.

This eye liner is so good inside or outside the eye.. just superb! I love england for the awareness of mother earth and animal's suffer.

Never thought I would wear blue eyeliner. Too 80's I thought. Until my friend tried this product on my and it looked great. Really enhances the colour of your eyes so instantly bought it. Hooray.